Animal tests are poor models for human diseases

It’s not only their track record in breast cancer research that puts Breast Cancer UK on the map but also how they carry out their research, which has made it quite unique compared to many other cancer charities.

Amongst the values and convictions of the charity’s founders, one has particularly stood out as being forward-thinking and progressive: its animal-free research policy. It has long formed part of the culture of the organisation.

The policy led to Breast Cancer UK’s collaboration with Animal Free Research UK. This partnership has enabled the charity to demonstrate its guiding principles and, more importantly, to fund a world of research without animals at its centre.

Chief Executive of Animal Free Research UK, Carla Owen, believes Breast Cancer UK has been a pioneer in this field. “Most medical research charities, including many big-named charities, are still funding animal research,” she says. “Going against that grain shows great conviction.”

The two charities are currently collaborating to fund research examining how hormone-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) may change breast density, which could affect a person’s breast cancer risk.

The research uses a fully humanised animal-free model. It enables scientists to look at the effects of EDCs on human fibroblast breast cells using a novel 3D human mammary gland model, representing the human breast more closely than in animal models. It looks and behaves like human breast tissues, so it more accurately reflects human disease.

Animal tests

“Animal tests are poor models for human diseases, and results from these studies often fail to translate to humans,” says Carla Owen.

“Inserting human cancer cells into mice, for example, doesn’t allow scientists to get a true picture of what happens in humans because the microenvironment in which the cells grow is not human. These scientific limitations are responsible for 90% of new drugs failing in clinical trials despite having shown promise in animals.

“We believe the best outcomes can be achieved by developing human-relevant methods to study human disease. Such as using human cells and tissues and replicating their environment.”

“It really stems back to the values of Breast Cancer UK’s founders. Which are reflected across all of our work from the ethical and environmental principles that underpin our research and our awareness-raising,” says Breast Cancer UK’s CEO, Thalie Martini.  “We know the fact that we don’t fund animal research matters for many of our supporters. And we are excited about new 3D breast culture models being developed and refined,” she says. “Our  collaboration with Animal Free Research UK demonstrates our commitment to ensuring animals don’t suffer in the name of breast cancer research.”

The future of animal testing

Today animal-free techniques in medical research are at the forefront of exciting new developments. Both charities firmly believe the future is bright for cancer research.

“Although there are still some outdated and entrenched views on the necessity of animal research, we aim for a future where modern techniques replace the use of animals. Where medicines are developed without using any animals by 2040,” says Carla Owen.

“Each year in the UK, three million animals are still used in research, and that’s simply not necessary. It’s in all our interests to ensure that pioneering, ethical research becomes the gold standard in UK labs – saving lives, money, and time.”

More about Breast Cancer UK’s animal-free research can be found here. Read about Animal Free Research UK’s work here.

Why not celebrate Breast Cancer UK’s 20^th anniversary and the life of animals? Donating to BCUK’s animal-free research or AFRUK’s work.

Animal Research – some of the facts 

• Each year in Britain, some three million animals* are used in research, including for human medicines and diseases. (2019*)
• 90% of new medicines that look promising in animal tests fail in human trials. This is because they are unsafe or do not work in humans due to significant differences in our genetic makeup.
• 6  animals are used every minute of the day in research in the UK

Help us prevent breast cancer by supporting our work.

By donating £20 today you can help fund vital research into the causes of breast cancer. So we can reduce the number of people who have to go through the heartache of a diagnosis and treatment. 

Together we can prevent breast cancer.

Donate today