1 December, 2015

Breast Cancer UK’s response to the Consultation on the Draft Opinion of the Committee for Socio-Economic Analysis. The Annex XV dossier proposed restrictions on BPA in thermal paper.

Breast Cancer UK is dedicated to the prevention of breast cancer. In the hope of reducing public exposure to the carcinogenic, hazardous and hormone disrupting chemicals routinely found in the environment and everyday products. We welcome the opportunity to comment on the Committee for Socio-Economic Analysis (SEAC) draft opinion on restrictions on Bisphenol A (BPA) in thermal paper.

Breast Cancer UK support fully the restriction proposal of bisphenol A (BPA) in thermal paper to reduce worker, consumer and environmental exposures.

Numerous studies, including many cited in the Committee for risk assessment (RAC) report, have demonstrated that BPA alters mammary tissue. Including changes likely to increase breast cancer risk. The restriction proposal addresses the risks to the human health of pregnant women and their unborn children. As documented in the RAC report, studies have shown that fetal exposure to BPA at environmentally relevant doses alters animal mammary glands. It will likely affect human mammary glands, resulting in breast cancers in later life. Evidence also suggests BPA exposure affects the female reproductive system, metabolism, obesity, the brain and behaviour and the immune system.

Breast Cancer UK believe the restriction should be extended to other bisphenols which may be used as BPA substitutes.

These are also suspected of being similarly toxic and damaging to human health and the environment. The RAC considered imposing a ban on all bisphenols in thermal paper. But dismissed this option due to a lack of toxicology data. We fully support SEAC’s suggestion that a restriction proposal on BPS should be carried out if a restriction on BPA is implemented.

Breast Cancer UK is disappointed that SEAC considers the proposed restriction on BPA in the thermal paper “unlikely to be a proportionate measure in terms of standard benefit-cost considerations”. We disagree with this strongly. Based on the conclusion, we do not believe a “break-even level of benefits” is an appropriate way to assess potential breast cancers. And other health outcomes associated with BPA. SEAC acknowledge that “adverse health effects arising from exposure to BPA can occur to the descendants of exposed female cashiers and consumers”. And “action to address risks to human health aimed at workers is justified on an EU-wide basis”. And “that the proposal is implementable, enforceable and manageable”. Despite this, SEAC has described the restriction as unlikely proportionate. Based on calculations of excess risk estimates of specific health outcomes versus substitution costs.

SEAC argues the largest benefits are likely to be achieved if substitution from BPA is to a non-bisphenol alternative

We agree strongly with – and estimate the corresponding costs would be €43 – €86 million annually. If the costs are transferred into increased prices of consumer goods, the amount per EU citizen will amount to ca. €0.1 – €0.2 per person per year. The draft opinion states that for the health benefits of the restriction to offset the total costs of transition to a non-bisphenol alternative, the hypothetical absolute risk reduction for the given adverse effects would have to be (medium cost):

  • 5% having mammary gland changes,
  • 8% having immunotoxicity-related allergies,
  • 2% having neurobehavioral effects,
  • 6% experiencing adverse reprotoxic effects
  • 4% having hypercholesterolemia or weight gain.

The relatively trivial costs of removing BPA are equated with potentially enormous costs to human health. Including probable increases in breast cancer incidence. Furthermore, this cost-benefit analysis does not consider the personal costs to those suffering from breast cancer. And other health impacts associated with BPA exposures.

SEAC estimate that 39,500 female babies may be at risk of changes. Due to their mammary glands following in-utero exposure to BPA in thermal paper. If a quarter of these children develop breast cancer, this would equate to around 10,000 additional breast cancer cases.

Breast Cancer UK strongly supports the proposed restrictions of BPA in the thermal paper. As outlined in the Annex XV dossier as a means of helping to protect future generations from an environmental health hazard.

Related Articles

30 November 2020

Call for urgent action on harmful chemicals

Breast Cancer UK calls on Government to give the new National Institute for Health Protection responsibility for regulating harmful chemicals Today, Breast Cancer UK, alongside our friends at ChemTrust, Alliance...

Read full story

20 March 2020

COVID-19 update from our CEO

Breast Cancer UK are living during a difficult time with the global pandemic of COVID-19.  We are especially concerned for those of us who are living with pre-existing health conditions,...

Read full story

16 July 2019

Launch of Environmental Audit Committee Report

Breast Cancer UK welcomes today’s publication of the Environmental Audit Committee’s report on Toxic Chemicals in Everyday Life. And its recommendations to deal with the growing problem of chemical pollution...

Read full story
Professor Val Speirs

A £10 donation today can help fund our PHD studentships to carry out world-class animal free research into the causes of breast cancer.


Donate £10
Woman on zoom call

A donation of £30 can help fund our Prevention Hub so your loved ones can learn how to reduce their risk.

Donate £20
people holding up hearts

Your donation of £50 can fund our animal free research and educational programmes to prevent breast cancer for future generations.

Donate £50

Just want to help in some way? donate an amount that feels right for you

Start Your Donation

Donate Now

Make a Donation


My One Time Donation

I want to make a one time donation of

Thank you. You’re just a few steps away from completing your donation.

+25% with Gift Aid

If you are a UK taxpayer, the value of your gift can be increased by 25% under the Gift Aid scheme at no extra cost to you.

This means that your donation of £100.00 could be worth an extra £25.00 to us, and it doesn't cost you a penny!

My Monthly Donation

I want to make a monthly donation

You’re just a few steps away from completing your donation.

+25% with Gift Aid

If you are a UK taxpayer, the value of your gift can be increased by 25% under the Gift Aid scheme at no extra cost to you.

This means that your donation of £100.00 could be worth an extra £25.00 to us, and it doesn't cost you a penny!

One Time Donation Monthly Donation
Make a donation with Gift Aid

Gift Aid is reclaimed by the Breast Cancer UK from the tax that I pay for the current tax year. If I pay less Income Tax and/or Capital Gains Tax than the amount of Gift Aid claimed on all my donations, it is my responsibility to pay any difference. Breast Cancer UK will reclaim 25p in tax back for every £1 I donate.

Your payment details

Your donation amount

Donation Allocation (Optional)

Additional Comments (Optional)

Stay in Touch

We’d love to keep you posted on how your support can make a difference to Breast Cancer UK and the exciting ways you can support us in the future.

Please tick if you’re happy to receive information from us by:

By completing an online donation, your data will be handled in accordance with the Breast Cancer UK’s privacy policy, and the privacy policy of our payment processing supplier BBMS (a Blackbaud company).

Thank You Wall

If you donate over £50, as a way of saying thank you for your donation, we would like to feature your donation on our virtual thank you wall on our website.

Donations will only feature on the wall for up to two months depending on the level of donations we receive.

You must fill out all required fields before paying.


Need help making your donation?

If you need help to make a donation or have any questions about making one, please contact us…

Call 08456801322